What If the Insurance Company Ghosts You After an Accident in California?

Kristy BandY • June 7, 2025

Ghosting is bad enough in dating, but it’s life-altering when it comes to your insurance company. If it seems like your insurance company is dragging its feet with your personal injury claim, they may be trying to deliberately delay the settlement until you eventually wear down enough and take a lowball offer just to get it over with. Stonewalling, like any toxic relationship tactic, can be hard to spot and frustrating to deal with. Luckily, with the help of an experienced California personal injury attorney, you can expedite the process and get the compensation you deserve. 


Stonewalling Tactics Insurance Companies Use


Here are some stonewalling tactics insurance companies use on our clients all the time:



  • Radio silence: This is the most common and most annoying stonewalling technique. When the adjuster just goes silent and stops responding to any emails, phone calls, or letters, it can make you feel lost and unsure of what to do.
  • Saying they don’t have the authority to settle for the amount you requested: Insurance adjusters typically need to be authorized by a supervisor or higher-up to settle a claim, but if your adjuster repeatedly tells you they don’t have the authority, they’ve probably already made the decision to stonewall you.
  • Telling you they’re still reviewing your claim: If your adjuster tells you your claim is “in committee,” “waiting for the approval of a supervisor,” or is “under review by the home office,” they’re trying to keep you waiting by convincing you the wheels are in motion. When the “review process” takes ages, they are likely intentionally delaying the case.
  • Requiring more proof: After you submit all necessary documents - medical bills, evidence of lost wages, etc. - but the adjuster requires further proof without being clear why, then they’re playing a waiting game.
  • Moving claim files from one adjuster to another: It’s possible that your insurance company has a high turnover rate in their claims adjuster departments, but if you’re always talking with a new claims adjuster every time you call, they may be stonewalling you.
  • Leveraging one claim against another: If you have a property damage claim along with a claim for your injuries, for example, certain adjusters may tell you they can’t settle the property damage claim until you also settle your injury claim. They usually will force you to make the decision immediately, and for lower than appropriate. 


What If My Insurance Company Stonewalls Me?


If you experience one or more of these tactics from your insurer, here’s what you can do:

  • Wait and let the negotiations play out a little longer: If you’re not in a rush, you can let things play out on their schedule and see what happens. Just make sure you don’t let things drag out longer than the statute of limitations on filing a lawsuit.
  • Sending the adjuster a demand letter: This may speed things up, but you still need to keep the statute of limitations in mind.
  • You can get an experienced personal injury lawyer to fight for you: This is likely your best option. Insurance companies rarely settle up on their own when they know the person doesn’t have a lawyer. 


Contact Us Today


Don’t let insurance companies take advantage of you during trying times. Having an experienced personal injury lawyer on your side will help you get the compensation you are legally entitled to - after all, that’s why you’ve been faithfully paying your premiums. Call the Law Office of Ball & Yorke to consult with a top California personal injury attorney today.

Aerial view of a multi-lane highway interchange crossing over dark water and greenery.
June 16, 2026
What evidence is most important in a California motor vehicle accident claim? Learn how police reports, medical records, witness statements, and other evidence can strengthen your case.
By Kristy BandY June 13, 2026
Here’s what to do after a California accident if you were not at fault. Call the Law Office of Ball & Yorke to consult with a personal injury lawyer at 805-642-5177
May 27, 2026
Learn how comparative negligence affects California car accident claims. Law Office of Ball & Yorke provides legal assistance to injured individuals in Ventura.
By Kristy BandY May 15, 2026
Missing the deadline for filing a personal injury claim means you may forfeit the claim. Call the Law Office of Ball & Yorke for a lawyer today at 805-642-5177
By Kristy BandY April 10, 2026
Here’s how California calculates damages for pain and suffering in a personal injury case. Call the Law Office of Ball & Yorke for a consultation at 805-642-5177
By Kristy BandY March 11, 2026
Here’s how delaying medical treatment after an accident can cost you a personal injury claim. Call the Law Office of Ball & Yorke today at 805-642-5177
Fan of US $100 bills on a tan surface.
February 17, 2026
Who pays compensation in a California personal injury case? Learn how insurance, liability, and comparative fault affect injury claims in Ventura.
Rider on a motorcycle, driving on a road surrounded by trees; sunny day.
February 17, 2026
Learn the statute of limitations for a California motorcycle accident claim. Law Office of Ball & Yorke helps Ventura riders understand filing deadlines and protect their right to compensation.
White house with a dark roof and bay windows, set above green shrubs under a cloudy sky.
February 17, 2026
Common reasons real estate closings get delayed in California and how to prevent them. Law Office of Ball & Yorke assists Ventura buyers and sellers with closing issues.
Employment Law
By Kristy BandY February 10, 2026
Here’s what you should know about legal protections for employees under Federal and California law. Call The Law Office of Ball & Yorke at 805-642-5177